
It has always been the case that accomplished landscape photographers render many of their images with regions of the photograph that are black. This is the equivalent to clipping the shadows with modern day digital cameras. It is still possible to expose with the histogram show now clipped shadows if the black point is adjusted in either Lightroom or Photoshop.
Examples from the books of landscape masters that include photographs
with clipped shadows
1. Ansel Adams, Making of his 40 Most Recognized Photographs, 50% of the photos
2. Galen Rowel, Yosemite book, 50% of Photos have black regions
3. William Niell, Landscapes of Sprit: 30% of Photos have black regions
4. Ernst Hass, Creation: 30% of Photos have black regions
5. Art Wolfe, Rhythms: 30% of Photos have black regions
6. Jim Brandenburg, Chased by Light: 30% of Photos have black regions
7. Brenda Tharp: Creative Nature Photography: 25% of Photos have black regions
- This is an instructional book
Further Thoughts
The vast majority of the photos with total black (silhouetted) regions in the classic books resulted from the photographer’s decision regarding exposure rather than an exposure error of any sort.
Any inference that totally black regions in high quality landscape photo is the result of poor technique is simply not the case. Such methods have been widely acclaimed by the best landscape photographers from the earliest days through the present.